Patriots QB options to replace Drake Maye, from Jimmy Garoppolo to Will Levis – A promising season in Foxborough hit a sudden, painful speed bump on Sunday afternoon. During a 35-10 loss to the Detroit Lions in Week 10, New England Patriots franchise quarterback Drake Maye suffered what the team fears is a fractured ankle—an injury that could sideline him for an extended stretch, if not the remainder of the 2026 campaign.
Sitting at 5-5 just past the midway point of the schedule and heading into a timely Week 11 bye, head coach Mike Vrabel and offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels find themselves scrambling to keep their postseason hopes alive. With the NFL trade deadline already in the rearview mirror, New England cannot swing a deal to bring in a splashy starter. Instead, the front office is scouring the free-agent wire and rival practice squads to bolster a quarterback room currently consisting of only Tommy DeVito and seventh-round rookie Behren Morton.
While DeVito is currently expected to get the first crack at the starting job after throwing for 81 yards, a touchdown, and an interception in relief against Detroit, his uneven performance made one thing clear: the Patriots need reinforcements. From familiar veterans to high-upside reclamation projects, several realistic options stand out for New England during the bye week.
The Nostalgic Fit: Jimmy Garoppolo
If the Patriots want someone who can step off the street and immediately grasp the playbook, no name makes more sense than Jimmy Garoppolo. Drafted by New England in the second round back in 2014, the 35-year-old spent the first three-and-a-half years of his career learning behind Tom Brady in Josh McDaniels’ offense—and later reunited with McDaniels during a brief stint with the Las Vegas Raiders.
Garoppolo is currently a free agent after spending the past two seasons as Matthew Stafford’s backup with the Los Angeles Rams, where he last saw meaningful action in 2024 (throwing for 334 yards and two touchdowns in a single start). Because he isn’t tied to another roster, New England could sign him directly to the active roster or even stash him on the practice squad while he shakes off the rust.
The appeal here is plug-and-play efficiency. Garoppolo won’t stretch the field vertically, and durability has always been a question mark throughout his career. However, his quick release, veteran poise, and deep familiarity with McDaniels’ terminology make him the safest bet to keep the offense on schedule without asking him to play hero ball. Patriots QB options to replace Drake Maye
The Upside Swing: Will Levis
For a completely different flavor of quarterback play, Vrabel could look toward a former pupil currently sitting on the New York Jets’ practice squad. Will Levis, 27, was selected 33rd overall by the Tennessee Titans in 2023 when Vrabel was still calling the shots in Nashville. Although Levis went just 3-6 in nine starts as a rookie under Vrabel—and struggled through a 2-10 stretch the following year before missing the 2025 season following shoulder surgery—the physical tools that made him a high draft pick haven’t vanished. Acquiring Levis comes with a specific procedural hurdle: because he is on New York’s practice squad, NFL rules dictate that New England would have to sign him directly to its 53-man active roster. Patriots QB options to replace Drake Maye
Signing Levis would be a classic high-risk, high-reward gamble. Unlike Garoppolo, Levis possesses a cannon arm and enough athleticism to create outside of structure—traits that could inject life into a stagnant passing attack. On the flip side, his 21 career starts (3,899 passing yards, 21 touchdowns, 16 interceptions) were frequently marred by erratic decision-making and costly turnovers. Still, having a head coach who already knows how to manage his temperament could help unlock the best version of his game.
The Internal Option: Tommy DeVito
Before handing the keys to an outsider, New England will give Tommy DeVito a legitimate opportunity to prove he belongs. Having served as Maye’s backup through the first ten weeks of the season, DeVito already has chemistry with the starting offensive line and pass-catchers.
While his relief appearance against the Lions (12-of-24 passing) left plenty to be desired, jumping into a game cold against a surging Detroit defense is no easy task. Giving DeVito a full bye week of first-team reps could yield much cleaner results. Even if New England signs a veteran like Garoppolo, DeVito will likely get the nod in Week 12 simply because he has been in the building all year.
The Depth Play: Bailey Zappe
If the Patriots simply want a familiar emergency arm who won’t disrupt the quarterback room’s hierarchy, Bailey Zappe is also available on the open market. Cut by the Jets earlier this season after spending time on their practice squad, Zappe started eight games for New England between 2022 and 2023.
Zappe’s ceiling is noticeably lower than Levis’s, and he lacks Garoppolo’s proven track record of winning big games. However, he knows the facility, understands the pressure of playing in New England, and could easily be signed to the practice squad as low-cost insurance behind DeVito and Morton.
What Comes Next in Foxborough
Ultimately, New England’s decision comes down to philosophy. If Vrabel and McDaniels believe their defense and running game can carry a 5-5 squad into the AFC playoff picture, bringing in a steady, system-savvy veteran like Jimmy Garoppolo—or rolling with DeVito—offers the cleanest path to protecting the football. If they feel the offense needs a spark to keep pace in a competitive conference, poaching Will Levis from a division rival’s practice squad gives them a talented wildcard worth exploring. Either way, the bye week just became the most important stretch of the Patriots’ season. Patriots QB options to replace Drake Maye